Dissent by Design

How to play

Bring a decision someone already favours. Give each challenger a different role so the group hears more than one way to question the proposal.

2–7 participants
Contrarian cardFuturist cardMinimalist card

Play a round

  1. State the preferred decision

    The decision-maker says what they favour and why. Everyone else saves their own preference for the discussion after the vote.

  2. Deal roles and prepare

    Give each challenger one role. Take five minutes to prepare an argument or question.

  3. Hear every challenge

    Take turns presenting. The decision-maker listens and can ask clarifying questions.

  4. Vote, reveal and reflect

    Everyone, including the decision-maker, chooses a vote card and places it face down. Keep the other hidden. Flip together on three and ask what changed and why. Either answer is fine.

Same next step, different assessments

The team is considering switching delivery suppliers. A challenger suggests trialling the new supplier on one route first.

Assessment changed

“I was against switching because a failed rollout would disrupt every route. A one-route trial makes the risk manageable.”

Assessment unchanged

“I already thought a one-route trial was the safest way to test the supplier. I still do.”

Both people favour the trial. The cards show whether hearing the challenges changed each person’s assessment. The reveal leaves the decision open.

Print and assemble